How do you calculate a non-bank lender's efficiency ratio?
Operating expense over income before provisions: 48.7% for 84 Mexican non-bank lenders in 2026, why the same costs read 64.7% or 9.0% on other denominators, and how the segments change places.
A non-bank lender's efficiency ratio is its administrative and personnel expense divided by its operating income before loan-loss provisions. HR Ratings puts the 84 Mexican non-bank lenders it rates at 48.7% for the year to June 2026. Over income after provisions the same costs read 64.7%; over the loan book, 9.0%.
The numerator is settled, and the denominator decides the number
Every definition agrees on the top line: what it costs to run the lender, without interest expense and without provisions. The microfinance guidelines of CGAP, the poverty-finance group hosted by the World Bank, define operating expense (item I10) as personnel and administrative expense that «excludes financial expense and loan-loss provision expense». The disagreement is the bottom line.
The FDIC, in its Quarterly Banking Profile for the second quarter of 2026, divides «noninterest expense less amortization of intangible assets» by «net interest income plus noninterest income»: income before provisions. HR Ratings, the Mexican rating agency, writes «Administrative Expenses 12m / Total Operating Revenues 12m» in the glossary of its August 2026 sector analysis. CGAP's ratio R18 divides operating expense by the average gross loan portfolio, and the 2003 technical guide of the IDB and MicroRate says that ratio «is also commonly referred to as the efficiency ratio».
HR Ratings, NBFIs Sector Analysis 2026 (25 August 2026), twelve months to June 2026, 84 non-bank lenders; FDIC, Quarterly Banking Profile 2Q 2026, Notes to Users; CGAP, Definitions of Selected Financial Terms, Ratios and Adjustments (2003), R18. The second and third values are our computation from HR's figures.
| Reading | Numerator | Denominator | Who uses it | 84 Mexican lenders, June 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cost over income before provisions | Administrative and personnel expense | Net interest income plus fees and other operating income | HR Ratings, FDIC | 48.7% |
| Cost over income after provisions | The same | Operating income after loan-loss provisions | A lender reading its own income statement | 64.7%, derived |
| Cost over the loan book | The same | Average gross loan portfolio | CGAP, MicroRate | 9.0%, derived |
Ask which denominator before comparing two efficiency ratios. The numerator is the same in all three; the answer moves by a factor of seven.
HR Ratings divides by income before provisions, although its statement line sits after them
A lender benchmarking itself against HR's sample will reach for the consolidated income statement printed in the same report. Its line «Total Operating Inflows (Expenses)» follows the Mexican regulatory format and comes after loan-loss provisions. Divide 2025 administrative expense of 24,388 million by it, 36,855 million, and the result is 66.2%. HR prints 49.8%.
The gap closes when provisions go back in. By our computation, 36,855 plus 12,095 of provisions is 48,950, and 24,388 over 48,950 is 49.8%. 2023 behaves the same way: 69.3% over the statement line, 53.8% with provisions added back, which is the figure HR prints. The agency's denominator is income before provisions, the same family as the FDIC formula, and a different line from the one its own statement labels.
HR Ratings, NBFIs Sector Analysis 2026 (25 August 2026), consolidated income statement and financial metrics of 84 non-bank lenders, millions of local currency as reported, full years. The two ratios above the last row are our computation; the last row is the ratio HR prints.
| Line | 2023 | 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Financial margin | 34,933 | 45,817 |
| Loan-loss provisions | 8,362 | 12,095 |
| Total operating inflows, after provisions | 28,998 | 36,855 |
| Administration expenses | 20,092 | 24,388 |
| Expenses over the statement line | 69.3% | 66.2% |
| Expenses over the line plus provisions | 53.8% | 49.8% |
| Efficiency ratio as HR prints it | 53.8% | 49.8% |
Recomputed for two years, HR's efficiency ratio matches only the denominator before provisions. Over the statement's own operating line the sample costs 15.5 points more in 2023 and 16.4 in 2025.
So the sample's 48.7% for the year to June 2026 belongs next to the 55.38% the FDIC reports for all 4,238 insured US institutions in the second quarter of 2026, and next to 53.15% for the consumer lenders among them. It does not belong next to 64.7%, which is what the same costs look like over income after provisions.
Gap in 2025 between HR's efficiency ratio and the same costs over its statement's operating line
Our computation from HR Ratings' consolidated statement of 84 Mexican non-bank lenders, August 2026.
Five steps compute it from a lender's own statements
The calculation needs an income statement for each of the last four quarters and the gross loan book at every month end. The steps below give the two readings a fund will compare.
- Add up twelve months of administrative and personnel expense, the line HR Ratings calls gastos de administración. Leave out interest expense, loan-loss provisions and one-off items such as the sale of a branch.
- Build income before provisions: the financial margin, plus fees collected less fees paid, plus intermediation and other operating income. On a statement in the Mexican regulatory format it is the operating income line with the loan-loss provisions added back.
- Divide the first sum by the second. That is the figure to set beside HR Ratings' segments and the FDIC's banks.
- Divide the same expense by the average gross loan book over the twelve months, taken from month-end balances rather than two year-end points. That is the figure a microfinance fund, or a reader of MicroRate, expects.
- Write both formulas under the table, with the statement lines each one uses, so a fund that recomputes the ratio from the statements lands on the same number.
Growth moves the ratio before anything else does. Staff and systems for a new product are paid for months before its loans earn, so a lender that doubles its book usually reports a worse ratio in the year it expands. Twelve months of expense over twelve months of income smooths the seasons; it does not remove the build-up, and a fund that sees a rising ratio asks whether the book or the cost base grew first.
The two ratios rank the same lenders in a different order
HR splits its sample into four segments. Over income before provisions, payroll lenders run at 38.9%, agricultural lenders at 47.4%, SME lenders at 51.2% and microfinance lenders at 58.2%. Over the average loan book, by our computation from the same tables, the order changes: agricultural 3.6%, SME 5.2%, payroll 6.8%, microfinance 23.8%.
HR Ratings, NBFIs Sector Analysis 2026 (25 August 2026), segment tables, twelve months to June 2026. HR's efficiency ratio as printed; the other columns are our computation: the same expense over income after provisions, over the average book, and income before provisions over the average book. Income before provisions is administrative expense over HR's ratio; the average book is the mean of June 2025 and June 2026.
| Segment | HR ratio, before provisions | After provisions | Over average book | Income over book |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Payroll lenders | 38.9% | 50.4% | 6.8% | 17.4% |
| Agricultural lenders | 47.4% | 71.6% | 3.6% | 7.7% |
| All 84 lenders | 48.7% | 64.7% | 9.0% | 18.5% |
| SME lenders | 51.2% | 63.4% | 5.2% | 10.1% |
| Microfinance lenders | 58.2% | 80.2% | 23.8% | 40.9% |
A ratio over income forgives high costs to whoever lends at high rates. Microfinance trails SME lenders by 7 points over income and costs 4.6 times as much per unit of book.
Yield explains the swap. Microfinance lenders earn 40.9% of their book in operating income before provisions; SME lenders earn 10.1%. MicroRate saw the same trap in its 2003 guide: comparing BancoSol's operating expense ratio of 12.2% with 33.9% at Compartamos «would be highly misleading», because their average loans were 1,842 and 290 dollars. Its answer was cost per borrower, where «institutions with larger loans do not automatically appear more efficient».
A modelled lender shows the size of the provision gap. Take an average book of 100, a yield of 45%, funding at 10% on 70% of the book, fees of 1, provisions of 8 and operating expense of 18. Income before provisions is 39.0 and after them 31.0. The ratio reads 46.2% before provisions and 58.1% after; expense over the book is 18.0%. The second reading rises with every point of credit loss, although the cost of running the lender did not change.
A fund reads efficiency in diligence and tests profit in the covenant
The Lenders' Guidelines for Setting Covenants in Support of Responsible Microfinance, drafted from June 2011 by AFD, PROPARCO, Oikocredit, Incofin and other lenders, list seven financial covenants. The section headed «Efficiency and Profitability» holds one: return on assets above 0% and below 10%. There is no efficiency covenant. A fund looks at cost when it reads the statements, and in the loan agreement it tests what is left after costs.
Questions this raises
- What is a lender's efficiency ratio?
- Operating expense, meaning personnel and administration without interest expense and provisions, divided by operating income before loan-loss provisions. A lower ratio means a cheaper lender.
- What formula does HR Ratings use for the efficiency ratio?
- Administrative expenses for twelve months over total operating revenues for twelve months. Recomputed from its 2023 and 2025 statements, the denominator is operating income before loan-loss provisions.
- Is the cost-to-income ratio the same as the efficiency ratio?
- In the bank and HR Ratings sense, yes. Microfinance analysts following CGAP and MicroRate use the name for operating expense over the average gross loan portfolio, which gives a much smaller number.
- What efficiency ratio do Mexican non-bank lenders run at?
- 48.7% for HR Ratings' sample of 84 rated non-bank lenders in the twelve months to June 2026: 38.9% for payroll lenders, 47.4% agricultural, 51.2% SME and 58.2% microfinance.
- What is a good efficiency ratio for a lender?
- None of the primary sources sets a threshold. Compare on the same formula: 55.38% for all US insured institutions in the second quarter of 2026, 48.7% for HR Ratings' Mexican sample.
- Do credit lines carry an efficiency covenant?
- The 2011 Lenders' Guidelines for responsible microfinance do not. Their efficiency and profitability section tests return on assets, above 0% and below 10%.
Where every figure on this page comes from 5 sources
- 01HR Ratings, NBFIs Sector Analysis 2026, 25 August 2026: glossary (Efficiency Index), consolidated income statement and financial metrics, segment tables for agricultural, microfinance, payroll discount and SME lenders; audited quarterly data of 84 financial institutions.
- 02FDIC, Quarterly Banking Profile, Second Quarter 2026, 25 August 2026: Table III-A (efficiency ratio by asset concentration group) and Notes to Users (definition of the efficiency ratio).
- 03CGAP, Microfinance Consensus Guidelines: Definitions of Selected Financial Terms, Ratios, and Adjustments for Microfinance, September 2003: I10 operating expense, R18 operating expense ratio.
- 04Inter-American Development Bank and MicroRate, Performance Indicators for Microfinance Institutions: Technical Guide, third edition, 2003: operating expense ratio and cost per borrower.
- 05Lenders' Guidelines for Setting Covenants in Support of Responsible Microfinance (AFD, PROPARCO, Oikocredit, Incofin and others), from June 2011: financial covenants, section B, Efficiency and Profitability.