How do you calculate cumulative net loss (CNL) on a loan pool?
Defaults since the cut-off date, less recoveries, over the pool's original principal: what four credit documents fix in writing, how a trigger schedule rises by month, and what Mexican rated pools measure instead.
Cumulative net loss is the principal of every loan in a pool that has defaulted since the cut-off date, less what has been recovered on those loans, divided by the principal the pool started with. It is read pool by pool and month by month, and a credit line tests it against a schedule that rises with the pool's age.
Three choices make the formula, and credit documents write all three down
The ratio looks the same in every document: cumulative defaults, less recoveries, over the original balance. The numbers differ because each document fixes three things. The first is when a loan counts as defaulted. The 2023 indenture of NetCredit Combined Receivables, an Enova vehicle, filed as an exhibit to Enova's 10-Q, counts a receivable as charged off once it is «65 or more days past due» or written off under the servicing policy. The second is what is netted: «Net Liquidation Proceeds» there, «all Recoveries» in the Conn's 2023-A notes (Form 8-K, August 2023), what came back after default.
The third is the denominator, and it is the one lenders get wrong. Every document here divides by principal at the start: «the Original Receivable Principal Balance» for NetCredit, the balance «as of the Cut-Off Date» for Conn's, the principal «at the time of origination» of each vintage, the loans originated in the same month, in the credit agreement between Consumer Portfolio Services (CPS) and Citibank. Oportun's 2024 amendment counts only losses after its revolving period ends, over the balance on that date.
NetCredit Combined Receivables 2023 indenture (Enova, 10-Q, exhibit 4.3); Conn's Receivables Funding 2023-A Series Supplement (8-K, exhibit 4.2); Oportun CL Trust 2023-A, Amendment No. 1 (10-Q, exhibit 10.5); Page Eight Funding (CPS) with Citibank, Eighth Amended and Restated Credit Agreement (10-K, exhibit 10.1.8). All filed with the SEC, read 27 October 2026.
| Document | Default point | Netted | Denominator | What the test does |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NetCredit, 2023 | 65+ days or charged off | Net liquidation proceeds | Original principal sold to the issuer | Breach sends all cash to the notes |
| Conn's 2023-A | Defaulted receivable | All recoveries | Balance at the cut-off date | Breach moves principal to the senior class |
| Oportun, 2024 | Defaulted receivable | Recoveries | Balance when revolving ends | Tested in amortisation only |
| CPS and Citibank, 2024 | Liquidated receivable | Net of recoveries | Vintage principal at origination | Projected CNL feeds the advance rate |
The denominator never moves after the start. What changes from deal to deal is the day a loan becomes a loss and the date the clock starts.
Divide by the current balance and the same pool looks twice as bad by month 12
By our computation, take a modelled pool of 10,000,000 in two-year instalment loans, where 10.35% of principal defaults over its life and a quarter of each default comes back within six months. By month 12 the pool has lost 5.75% of its original principal, net of recoveries. Only 44.2% of it is still outstanding, so the same losses over the current balance read 13.01%. By month 18 it is 7.42% against 39.63%. The ratio over the current balance rises because the pool shrinks, not because it performs worse, and no credit document above uses it.
Our computation, a modelled pool of 10,000,000 in 24-month equal-principal loans; defaults shaped to peak in months 6 to 9; recoveries of 25% of defaulted principal, 10% after one month, 10% after three, 5% after six. Percent of original principal unless stated.
| Months on book | Defaults, cumulative | Recoveries, cumulative | CNL over original | Balance left | Losses over balance left |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Month 3 | 0.40% | 0.01% | 0.39% | 87.1% | 0.45% |
| Month 6 | 2.40% | 0.20% | 2.20% | 72.7% | 3.03% |
| Month 9 | 4.90% | 0.67% | 4.23% | 58.1% | 7.28% |
| Month 12 | 7.00% | 1.24% | 5.75% | 44.2% | 13.01% |
| Month 18 | 9.55% | 2.12% | 7.42% | 18.7% | 39.63% |
| Month 24 | 10.35% | 2.52% | 7.83% | 0.0% | Not defined |
Lifetime CNL is 7.76%, reached after the last recovery. The ratio over the current balance has no ceiling, which is why no credit document tests it.
CNL can fall. In our computation, after the last default, late recoveries keep arriving, and the modelled pool ends at 7.76% after standing at 7.83% in month 24. The ratio is built per pool, one origination cohort at a time, which is why it lives in a static pool table: each row a vintage, each column a month on book.
The trigger is a schedule by month, and it starts with more room than the pool needs
A credit line does not test CNL against one number. NetCredit's indenture, an exhibit to Enova's 10-Q of July 2024, sets a level for every collection period: 5.00% in the first two, 7.50% in the third, 20.00% in the sixth, 32.50% in the twelfth and 45.00% from the twenty-fourth. Conn's 2023-A notes write theirs by calendar month: 4.00% in September 2023, 9.64% in February 2024, 17.33% in August 2024 and 29.60% from July 2025, next to a separate annualised net loss test of 40.00%. Once CNL exceeds the level, NetCredit's notes enter an amortisation event and all remaining collections pay them down; at Conn's, principal goes to the senior class first.
Trigger levels from the NetCredit 2023 indenture (by collection period) and the Conn's 2023-A Series Supplement (by determination date, September 2023 as month 1). Shares of the final level and the modelled pool's share of its lifetime CNL are our computation.
| Month | NetCredit level | Share of its final 45.00% | Conn's level | Share of its final 29.60% | Modelled pool, share of lifetime CNL |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Month 1 | 5.00% | 11% | 4.00% | 14% | 0% |
| Month 3 | 7.50% | 17% | 5.98% | 20% | 5% |
| Month 6 | 20.00% | 44% | 9.64% | 33% | 28% |
| Month 12 | 32.50% | 72% | 17.33% | 59% | 74% |
| Month 18 | 37.50% | 83% | 24.25% | 82% | 96% |
| Month 24 | 45.00% | 100% | 29.60% | 100% | 100% |
The cushion is widest early and narrows towards the end. A pool that breaches in month 6 is losing far faster than the deal was priced for, not running slightly late.
A young pool is projected to its lifetime loss by dividing by a timing curve
Six months of CNL say little until they are set against the curve older pools followed. The 2024 credit agreement between CPS and Citibank, filed with CPS's 10-K, writes the method down: «Projected CNL» is «the quotient resulting from dividing the most current Cumulative Net Loss Rate for such Vintage Pool … by the corresponding point on the applicable timing curve», and the projections are updated «in the Advance Rate Calculator on each Settlement Date». The curve itself is redacted in the filing; the mechanics are not.
In our computation on the modelled pool, older vintages reach 28.3% of their lifetime CNL by month 6 and 74.1% by month 12. A new vintage that shows 2.86% at month 6 projects to 2.86 divided by 0.283, or 10.1% over its life, against 7.76% for the history. The lender sees the deterioration eighteen months before the last loan is due, and so does the fund, through a lower advance rate.
Share of lifetime net loss a modelled two-year pool has taken by month 6
Our computation; the timing curve divides a young pool's CNL to project its lifetime loss.
A Mexican rated history measures gross default by cohort, not CNL
Mexican lenders that have issued on the stock exchange already keep vintage data, but HR Ratings reads it differently. It rates the trust certificates by comparing the Mora Máxima, the share of expected collections a structure survives losing in its stress case, with the Tasa de Incumplimiento Histórica, the historical default rate of the originator's cohorts, and states the ratio as Veces Tasa de Incumplimiento. The historical rate counts loans that fell past due in each cohort, not what was finally lost after recoveries, and the definition changes by deal, from the weighted cumulative default of each cohort at HIR Casa to the weighted average of the three most recent mature cohorts at TIP Auto.
HR Ratings rating reports and stock exchange notices: CONCRCB 26S (19 August 2026), EXITUCB 26 (26 May 2026), ENGENCB 26 (27 April 2026), HIRCB 25 (24 June 2026), TIPMXCB 23 (22 August 2025). Historical default is the agency's Tasa de Incumplimiento Histórica; stress loss its Mora Máxima; the multiple is one over the other.
| Issue and originator | Historical default | Stress loss survived | Multiple | Trigger in the deal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CONCRCB 26S, FinCrementar | 7.8% | 36.1% | 4.7x | Not stated in the notice |
| EXITUCB 26, Exitus Capital | 5.5% | 26.6% | 4.8x | Past-due book above 5.0% |
| ENGENCB 26, Engencap | 3.9% | 23.4% | 5.9x | Not stated in the summary |
| HIRCB 25, HIR Casa | 4.2% | 29.3% | 7.0x | Adjusted delinquency above 7.0% |
| TIPMXCB 23, TIP Auto | 1.0% | 22.1% | 22.5x | Balance 120+ days late above 8.0% |
None of these deals tests net loss over original principal. Their triggers read a stock of late loans, so the same history has to be restated before it answers a US-style schedule.
The triggers are the clearest difference. In HR Ratings' August 2025 review, TIP Auto's certificates name theirs «Pérdidas Acumuladas», accumulated losses, but define it as the balance of assets more than 120 days late over total assets, a stock read on each date; above 8.0% for more than two consecutive payment dates in the revolving period, amortisation accelerates. Exitus tests a cartera vencida ratio of 5.0%. Exitus's cohorts count a default at more than 90 days and leave out eleven clients who paid in full, on average 1.37 months after falling past due.
So the restatement a fund will ask for is mechanical. Take each monthly vintage, mark a loan defaulted at the day count the term sheet uses, subtract every recovery on it, and divide the running total by the vintage's original principal. Lay the curves on the proposed schedule month by month. The gap at month 6 and at month 12 is the headroom the lender is negotiating.
Definitions and trigger levels are the credit documents', the Mexican pools HR Ratings'; the worked pool, the timing curve and the shares of the schedules are our computation from them.
Questions this raises
- What is cumulative net loss?
- The principal of every loan in a pool that has defaulted since the cut-off date, less recoveries on those loans, divided by the pool's original principal. Credit documents test it pool by pool and month by month.
- What is the formula for cumulative net loss?
- CNL equals cumulative defaulted principal minus cumulative recoveries, divided by original pool principal. The NetCredit 2023 indenture counts a loan as defaulted at 65 or more days past due, nets liquidation proceeds and divides by the original principal sold to the issuer.
- What is a cumulative net loss trigger?
- A schedule of maximum CNL levels by month of the pool's life. NetCredit's 2023 indenture rises from 5.00% in the first collection period to 45.00% from the twenty-fourth; above it, an amortisation event sends all remaining collections to repay the notes.
- Why divide by the original balance and not the current one?
- The current balance falls as loans pay down, so losses over it rise even when the pool performs as expected. In a modelled two-year pool, 5.75% of original principal lost by month 12 reads 13.01% of the balance still outstanding, by our computation.
- How do you project lifetime CNL from a young pool?
- Divide its current CNL by the share of lifetime loss older pools had reached at the same month, the timing curve. The 2024 credit agreement between Consumer Portfolio Services and Citibank uses this projection in its advance rate calculator.
- Do Mexican securitisations use CNL?
- The rated ones HR Ratings reviewed in 2025 and 2026 compare a stress loss with a gross historical default rate by cohort, and their triggers read a stock of late loans, such as the balance over 120 days late at TIP Auto, 8.0%.
Where every figure on this page comes from 9 sources
- 01NetCredit Combined Receivables 2023, LLC, Indenture dated 3 March 2023, Appendix A: Charged-Off Receivable, Cumulative Net Losses, Cumulative Net Loss Ratio, Cumulative Net Loss Trigger, Amortization Event. Enova International, 10-Q filed 24 July 2024, exhibit 4.3.
- 02Conn's Receivables Funding 2023-A, LLC, Series 2023-A Supplement dated 17 August 2023: Cumulative Net Loss Percentage, Cumulative Net Loss Trigger, Annualized Net Loss Trigger. Conn's, Inc., 8-K filed 22 August 2023, exhibit 4.2.
- 03Oportun CL Trust 2023-A, Amendment No. 1 to Receivables Loan and Security Agreement dated 22 March 2024: Amortization Period Cumulative Net Losses, CNL Trigger Test (levels redacted). Oportun Financial, 10-Q filed 10 May 2024, exhibit 10.5.
- 04Page Eight Funding LLC, Consumer Portfolio Services and Citibank, Eighth Amended and Restated Credit Agreement dated 1 November 2024: Cumulative Net Loss Rate, Projected CNL, Projected CNL Matrix, Exhibit D timing curve (redacted). Consumer Portfolio Services, 10-K filed 16 March 2026, exhibit 10.1.8.
- 05HR Ratings, CONCRCB 26S (FinCrementar), stock exchange notice of 19 August 2026.
- 06HR Ratings, EXITUCB 26 (Exitus Capital, S.A.P.I. de C.V., SOFOM, E.N.R.), initial rating report of 26 May 2026: vintage analysis and trigger de cartera vencida.
- 07HR Ratings, ENGENCB 26 and 26-2 (397 CAP, S.A. de C.V., SOFOM, E.N.R., and Engencap Fin), initial rating report of 27 April 2026.
- 08HR Ratings, HIRCB 25 and 25-2 (Bienes Programados, HIR Casa), review of 24 June 2026.
- 09HR Ratings, TIPMXCB 23 and 23-2 (TIP Auto, S.A. de C.V., SOFOM, E.N.R., and TIP de México), review of 22 August 2025: glossary (Pérdidas Acumuladas, Tasa de Incumplimiento Histórica) and trigger de pérdidas acumuladas.